Wees jezelf; de rest is al bezet.
— Oscar Wilde
Dit is het eerste bericht op mijn nieuwe blog. Deze blog is pas net opgericht, dus kom snel terug voor meer. Meld je hieronder aan om een bericht te ontvangen wanneer ik nieuwe berichten plaats.
Wees jezelf; de rest is al bezet.
— Oscar Wilde
Dit is het eerste bericht op mijn nieuwe blog. Deze blog is pas net opgericht, dus kom snel terug voor meer. Meld je hieronder aan om een bericht te ontvangen wanneer ik nieuwe berichten plaats.
A lot of right wing voices in the political debate, especially in the deeply religious United States, love to call anything associated with leftism, socialism or government intervention in general ‘ungodly’, ‘unchristian’ or any term with a similar meaning and connotation. I would argue that this name calling is not only immature and lacks argumentative depth, but is also grossly incorrect.
For if we look at the way of living of early Israeli Jews, which is often seen as the model of a christian society, we should conclude that leftism might not be so ‘ungodly’ after all. These Israeli Jews lived in a commune that had shared resources that vulnerable or unlucky members of their commune could take from in times of need. This is the same kind of solidarity that can be found in leftist ideologies and that is the fundament of leftist projects like the welfare state or international solidarity.
Thus, if anything, solidarity and leftism is not only compatible with christianity, it is even prescribed. One could even go so far as to argue that if one wishes to be a good christian, one should be, at least to some extent, economically left wing. Medieval political philosophers realised this fact. Now is the turn for contemporary right wingers.
Last week, in this blog I have argued based on the example of Maimonides that we should be cautious to accept claims of absolute truth about the universe. I have argued that there is no shame to being in doubt about the big questions and that there are so many different contradicting answers to these questions that perplexity is not irrational. This week I will go even further. I will argue that not only do we not know the answers to the big questions with certainty, but also that even the rational secular philosopher can never be completely rational in all its beliefs.
For as Thomas of Aquinas argued in his Suma Theologica, even secular philosophers must hold beliefs that they have not acquired rationally. For every human is always shaped by its experiences. And it is impossible for someone to not occasionally rely on beliefs or statements of predessesors and others. Thus we must say that someone who claims to have come to its beliefs strictly rationally and completely without faith is delluding himself. Everyone has to rely on faith somewhere one way or the other, so let’s just be honest about this human limitation.
At the end of the twelfth century, the Jewish philosopher Maimonides wrote his famous Guide for the Perplexed. In this work, Maimonides tried to help people who were confused about their beliefs in God and the world by explaining how religious texts should be interpreted not literally. By doing this Maimonides tried to establish once and for all what the truth was, so that people would not have to be perplexed anymore. By doing this, Maimonides added one more truth to the list of thousands of other different truths about the world that have been offered by thousands of other different thinkers and religions over history.
With so many different contradicting truths about the universe, one starts to wonder how all these thinkers throughout history could be so sure to dismiss their perplexity. With so many different contradicting truths about the universe, one even starts to think that perplexity and doubt might actually be the rational state of mind. It is not a shame to be perplexed. Being perplexed is simply having the bravery to admit that you are not certain about the universe. And you shouldn’t be. The universe is extremely complex and it makes sense to admit you are perplexed. And anyone who is claiming to know the truth about the universe for certain is overestimating their own wisdom. So let’s stay perplexed for now and be wary of anyone who tries to cure you from it.
The medieval ages are often seen as a backwards period full of intolerance, superstition and different religious groups slaughtering each other. Because of this, the unflattering nickname of ‘The Dark Ages’ has proven to be persistent. Although I would by no means bagatilize the religious violence of the medieval ages, I believe that this image is wrong. To the contrary, I believe that in some ways, the medieval period can teach us a lot about tolerance.
Let us for example look at the traditions of medieval philosophy in different religions, especially the Jewish and Islamic tradition. The interesting thing of these traditions is that both of them heavily inspired and influenced the other. The Jewish tradition of Mutakallimun for example, that focused on a philosophical interpretation of scripture and revelation, was strongly influenced by the Islamic tradition of Kalam that aspired the same goals in Islam. The medieval ages were full of similar examples of traditions from different religions that inspired each other, breached religious barriers and created great philosophy along the way.
Today we could learn a thing or two from that. The interactions between different branches of modern philosophy, with its continental and analytical branches that interacted relatively little until recently, seem little in comparison. Perhaps it is time that we learn from how Jews and Muslims broke religious barriers in the medieval ages, so that we can break our non-religious barriers today.
In his famous The inconsistencies of the philosophers, El Ghazali showed how the Aristotelian tradition of medieval philosophers, and Avicenna in particular, contradicted itself. Because of this, El Ghazali is sometimes blamed for a perceived subsequent decline of Arab Philosophy. This has given El Ghazali the reputation of an anti-philosopher and a boogeyman for philosophers today. I would argue that that reputation is ridiculous and that instead El Ghazali should be an example for modern philosophers.
For all that El Ghazali did was show that arguments made by other people were inconsistent and did not work. So even apart from the fact that many historians disagree with the idea of a decline of Arab philosophy altogether, if anyone is to blame for it it should be the people that made the inconsistent arguments and not the one that pointed this out. In fact El Ghazali should be applauded for pointing out these inconsistencies, for with this he prevented serious decisions based on these unsound arguments.
And this should be exactly the job of modern philosophers. As philosophers equipped with a critical mind and knowledge of logic, it is their duty to show, just like El Ghazali did, inconsistencies in arguments. When a pseudo-scientist gives an argument against vaccinations, a philosopher should show its inconsistencies. When a politician gives a fatalistic or xenophobic speech, the philosopher should show its inconsistencies. When a bad argument is made, the philosopher should show its inconsistencies. Just like El Ghazali.
The Corona crisis will show whether Avicenna was right
The Arab philosopher Avicenna, who is often seen as of the greatest philosophers in world history, famously proclaimed that he stopped learning at the age of eighteen. With this, the self taught Avicenna tried to provoke people to teach themselves. For Avicenna was a big proponent of the autodidact, persons who teach themselves philosophy or other sciences without the help of a teacher. According to Avicenna, true understanding could not simply be gained by memorizing facts, but should be discovered by yourself. Unsurprisingly, Avicenna’s own writings where therefore not focused at simply stating a theory, but at triggering people to think for themselves. For Avicenna this was the best way to learn philosophy.
In the Corona crisis today, we are presented with a lot of bad news. However, there might be a little sprankle of good news as well, for in this crisis we will finally find out whether Avicenna was right about the autodidact. For the university of Leiden has cancelled all physical education until the end of the academic year, which will mean that students will lack physical lectures and will likely have to do more themselves at home. Everyone seems to agree that this will lead to worse results. The university has decided to postpone its binding study advice and many study programmes have decided to be more flexible in their exam norms. However if Avicenna is right, this doesn’t necessarily have to be the case. Perhaps the fact that students are forced to become more of an autodidact will not harm the results, but might actually lead to greater understanding of philosophy. If Avicenna is right, the closing of the physical university might be a blessing in disguise. Let’s hope he was.
Many of the greatest contributions to science have been made by polymaths, people that mastered several areas of study. It is therefore unfortunate that today the polymath seems to have become an endangered species. In part this is simply because the total amount of knowledge today is much larger than say a thousand years ago, making it much harder to master multiple subjects. However, this is not the only reason the polymath has become endangered: our modern university system arguably plays a large role in this as well.
To understand this, we need to make a comparison with the medieval madrasa, a . In the program of such a madrasa, students would learn not just one subject, but would learn everything from language sciences, logic, mathematics, physics, and metaphysics
to ethics and politics. Contrast this with the university today! Here the average student chooses just one subject, spends three to four years studying that subject in a bachelor’s program, then specializes even further within that single subject in its master’s program, until a select group goes even further and spends several years studying a yet much smaller subject in a doctoral thesis.
From an economic perspective, this makes sense in our specialized capitalistic job market. However, one could also argue that one who has studied more than just one subject and has mastered several is a more complete human being in its own right. Furthermore, if we think critically about what approach would actually contribute most to our scientific knowledge, we might not necessarily conclude that the specialstic approach would be best. If we look at some of the people that have contributed most to science like Aristotle, Al-Farabi or Isaac Newton or even when we look at the few remaining homo universali in our time such as Noam Chomsky, it might suggest that interdisciplinary knowledge might be a better basis for progress than extreme specialization. This leaves one to wonder whether a return to a system more in line with the madrasa might not be such a bad idea after all.
Everything I say is a lie. You are all awful human beings.
The sentence above is an example of a formulation of one of the most famous paradoxes in history: the liar’s paradox. By claiming that everything I say is a lie, I am also claiming that my claim that everything I say is a lie is a lie, which means that not everything I say is a lie. This leaves the reader going in circles, forced to admit a contradiction and doomed to utter confusion.
Or so it seems. Because on further examination, we must conclude that there is a way out of the liar’s paradox. Because we are not confronted with someone that always lies, but with someone that sometimes lies. For the first sentence simply can’t logically be true and therefore the speaker can not be someone that always lies (for the sentence is untrue), nor someone that never lies (for he lied in the first sentence) and must therefore be someone that sometimes lies. Of course, when you deposit an untrue premise in the first sentence, you will come to some strange or contradictory conclusions.. We see here a classic example of the strawman: an argument that puts words in a person’s mouth that that person would not have said. In this example that is letting the sometimes liar say he always lies. There is a group today that has learned a lot from these ancient and medieval paradoxes and have made the strawman (although a much less sophisticated version of it) their main weapon: Turning Point USA
This right wing activist group from the United States has made it their mission to fight perceived leftist propaganda on universities. Apart from initiatives like a professor’s watchlist for liberal professors, the organisation is also notorious for its attempts to dismantle leftist arguments by one of its figureheads Charlie Kirk. The vast bunch of all arguments made by him have the following structure: The left claims A, A leads to B, but the left doesn’t claim B, so the left must be hypocrite. Whether it is: “The US Government is the number one polluter in the world, so if you love the environment, why do you not want to shrink the government?” or “Bernie Sanders wants the American Government to provide every citizen with healthcare, food and housing, but aren’t those the same things that are provided to slaves and prisoners?”
Turning Point USA uses a strawman to put words in the mouths of its opposition that they would never say. Turning Point USA is deliberately trying to mischaracterize its opponents. Turning Point USA should not have a place in serious public discourse.
Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius had all the wealth, power and comfort a man could hope for. As master of the offices, he was one of the most powerful men in the Roman Empire and had he turned a blind eye to the corruption in the Empire, he would likely have remained in this comfortable position for the rest of his life. But Boethius did not choose such a life. Instead, Boethius openly criticized the corruption and incompetence that ruled the court of Rome. This outspokenness costed him his life. He was accused of treason, thrown in prison and eventually executed in 524. It is a tragedy that the bravery to speak out against the established order came at such a high cost and one could only hope that in our modern civilised societies injustices like that would be something from the past.
Unfortunately, that is far from so. Even today, our world is filled with Boethiusses. Where are they , Well let’s take a simple look around us. Let us look at Edward Snowden, who exposed the systematic violation of our privacy by NSA surveillance and had to flee to Russia. Let us look at Julian Assange, who created a platform to expose government corruption and has to live a life on the run. Let us look at the witnesses that exposed Donald Trump’s corruption in his impeachment trial, but were fired soon after it. Let us look at all the other whistleblowers in our world that sacrificed their freedom to expose injustices.
The whistleblower is the modern Boethius. Just like Boethius he is willing to speak out against injustices and corruption in the established order. Just like Boethius he is treated like a criminal because of his bravery. And just like Saint Boethius, history will look with shame upon how these men are treated. We should not prosecute these men, we should applaud them for their bravery. For if it is not they that expose the corruption of the established order, who will?
Men and women are historical beings. Religion has dominated our thinking for the great majority of history, so it would be foolish to discard its influence on our thought today. Nevertheless, nowadays we see a tendency by some to overestimate this remnant of religious influence. Some have even argued that the only reason we feel moral outrage towards evidently evil things, like the killing of babies for the sake of population control, is because of the remnants of religion.
Their argument goes somewhere along these lines. If one is a fully rational being, than he or she would have no reason to object to the killing of babies for the sake of population control. However, most of us do feel moral outrage when thinking about baby genocide. Thus, we are not completely rational beings, which means we must not have ridden our worldview completely of religious thought.
First of all, I believe the first premise of that argument is incorrect. I think it is perfectly possible to argue against the killing of babies on rational grounds. The fact that we have decided that population control is the goal to strive for is in itself not necessarily rational and even if we accept that as a goal, there are probably more rational alternatives than baby genocide to achieve it. However that is not the objection against the argument that I will make here. Instead I will argue against the claim that religion must be the source of our “irrational” outrage. I would argue that that is a hasty claim and that an alternative source of our outrage, human biology, is more plausible.
To understand this, I will first establish why the claim that religion is the source of our moral outrage towards killing baby’s does not work. For if we accept that claim, than its logical conclusion would be that this outrage would not exist if it were not for religion. So if we could find an example of a being that feels moral outrage, but is not influenced by religion, then the argument would lose much of its plausibility.
I believe there are two examples of which even the most ardent believers in the influence of religion could agree on that they are not (yet) influenced by religion: animals and babies. Research has shown that both of them show signs of morality and an aversion to killing their fellow species. The fact that these non-religious beings show moral outrage as well, suggests that religion can not be the (sole) source of it, for that would not explain why beings that can not possibly have been influenced by religion show these same feelings.
So we need to find an alternative source of our moral outrage. A more probable source of our moral outrage towards could be that it simply comes from our nature. This view is supported from the field of evolutionary biology, since there are evolutionary reasons to assume a natural source of our morality. For example, groups of animals take the interests of their group into account and don’t just consider individual interests have a higher chance of survival as a group than groups of animals where it is all for themselves. Thus groups of animals that take the group into consideration and have a moral compass will survive more and become evolutionary successful. Thus it is not implausible that nature and evolution are the cause of our moral outrages.
So to conclude, the claim that religion is the source of our aversion to baby genocide is likely false. Biological factors seem a more probable cause. So although we can’t escape the fact that religion still has influence on our worldview, we should not overestimate it either.
Heb je al een WordPress.com-account? Nu inloggen.